St. Lucia vs. St. Vincent: Which Sandals Is Right for Your Honeymoon
Two neighboring islands, two very different Sandals honeymoons.
Honeymoon & Milestone
St. Lucia · St. Vincent and the Grenadines
Adults-Only All-Inclusive
✦ Updated November 2026✦ Jea Breshears · Journeys with JB✦ 12 min read
Black Friday: Sandals savings through December 1
Sandals St. Lucia or Sandals St. Vincent is the comparison I get asked about most by honeymoon couples right now. The two islands are neighbors in the Windward Islands, and both have adults-only Sandals resorts built for couples, but they deliver very different honeymoons. St. Lucia offers three resorts on one island, more flight options and the Pitons. St. Vincent offers one newer, more secluded resort on a private cove, home to the first two-story overwater villas Sandals has built.
The short answer: choose St. Lucia for the most flight options, three resorts to use in one stay and the Pitons. Choose St. Vincent for Sandals' newest resort, a two-story overwater villa and a quieter island with fewer visitors.
Neither is the better island in general. The right one depends on how far you are willing to travel, how much variety you want across the week, and which room you have in mind. Here is how they compare.
Limited time
Sandals Black Friday Sale: Book by December 1
Both islands are part of the Sandals Black Friday sale, open for bookings through December 1, 2026 for stays through December 31, 2028.
Up to 65%
off qualifying stays
$2,000
in instant booking credit, at most
$750
in air credit, at most
- $250 spa credit on 5+ nights
- A free night on select 7-night stays
- Air credit for stays March 1 to October 2, 2027
- Stacks with Wednesday 777 deals
For a 2027 honeymoon, this is one of the strongest booking windows of the year. The air credit applies to stays between March 1 and October 2, 2027, so spring and early summer weddings line up well. Credits vary by resort, room category and length of stay, which means the same dates can price quite differently in St. Lucia and St. Vincent. Pricing both islands side by side is worth doing before the sale closes.
Watch for Sandals' 777 deals too. Every Wednesday, Sandals features seven room categories with an extra 7% off for seven days, and right now that discount stacks on top of the Black Friday savings. If the room you have in mind in St. Lucia or St. Vincent lands on a Wednesday list before December 1, the price drops again.
Offer details from Sandals Resorts. Savings, credits and free nights vary by resort, room category, travel dates and length of stay, and are subject to availability and Sandals' terms and conditions.
The Sandals Black Friday sale has ended, but Sandals runs new promotions often. Ask what is on right now.
At a glance
Sandals St. Lucia vs. Sandals St. Vincent: the four resorts compared
Three Sandals resorts in St. Lucia and one in St. Vincent. The full write-up on each island follows below.
Sandals St. Lucia Grand Bay, Sandals St. Lucia La Toc, Sandals St. Lucia Halcyon Beach and Sandals Saint Vincent compared for a honeymoon.
| Compare | Sandals St. Lucia Grand Bay | Sandals St. Lucia La Toc | Sandals St. Lucia Halcyon Beach | Sandals Saint Vincent |
| Island | St. Lucia, north coast | St. Lucia, near Castries | St. Lucia, near Castries | St. Vincent, Buccament Bay |
| Size | Large and lively | Large hillside estate, about 220 acres | The smallest of the three, about 194 rooms | 301 rooms and suites on about 50 acres |
| Beach and setting | The best beach of the three, on a peninsula | A half-mile crescent beach below the hills | A calm bay, low-key and leafy | A private cove ringed by rainforest |
| Signature stay | Overwater bungalows and Rondoval suites with plunge pools | Oceanfront villa suites with private pools | Shore House butler suites with private pools | Two-story overwater villas |
| Use of other resorts | Dine and play at all three St. Lucia resorts | Dine and play at all three St. Lucia resorts | Dine and play at all three St. Lucia resorts | Stand-alone, the only Sandals on the island |
| From the airport | About 1.5 to 2 hours from UVF | About 1 hour from UVF | About 1 hour from UVF | About 45 minutes by road, boat for Butler guests |
| Best for | Couples who want energy and the best beach | Couples who want a villa or views | Couples who want quiet and a smaller resort | Couples who want the newest resort and seclusion |
Transfer times are by road from Hewanorra International (UVF) in St. Lucia, where most US flights land, and Argyle International (SVD) in St. Vincent.
St. Lucia · Windward Islands
St. Lucia
Three resorts, one island
St. Lucia has three adults-only Sandals resorts, and a stay at any one of them includes dining and amenities at the other two, with shuttles between them. That arrangement is the main reason couples choose St. Lucia: a full week here rarely feels repetitive, and there are more restaurants to work through than most honeymoons have nights.
The three resorts
- Sandals St. Lucia Grand Bay (formerly Grande St. Lucian)
- On a peninsula near Rodney Bay, with the best beach of the three and the liveliest atmosphere. It has overwater bungalows, and Rondoval suites come with private plunge pools.
- Sandals St. Lucia La Toc (formerly Regency La Toc)
- A large hillside estate near Castries with a half-mile crescent beach and oceanfront villa suites with private pools.
- Sandals St. Lucia Halcyon Beach
- The smallest and quietest of the three, set between the other two, with a relaxed, low-key feel.
Airport
Hewanorra (UVF)
Setting
North and west coast
Pace
As busy or quiet as you like
Good to know
The Pitons are on the southwest coast, well south of all three resorts, so seeing them up close takes a full day by road or a catamaran trip down the coast. Golf green fees at the island's championship course are included for Sandals guests, which is a useful perk if one of you plays.
St. Vincent and the Grenadines · Windward Islands
St. Vincent
Sandals' newest, on a private cove
Sandals Saint Vincent (formerly Sandals Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) opened in March 2024 on Buccament Bay, and it is the only large resort on the island. Rainforest-covered mountains surround it, and St. Vincent still sees far fewer visitors than St. Lucia. This is the choice for couples who want to feel genuinely away.
What sets it apart
It introduced Sandals' first two-story overwater villas, ten of them, with glass floors and open-air day beds on the upper level. Rooms here are the largest in the Sandals portfolio, and the new Rondoval Butler Villas with private pools are the latest addition. Dining runs to 11 restaurants, including Buccan, a communal, family-style restaurant built around Vincentian cooking.
Airport
Argyle International (SVD)
Setting
Private cove, Buccament Bay
Pace
Slow and secluded
Good to know
St. Vincent is volcanic, so the resort's beach is imported white sand blended with the island's natural black sand. Pack insect repellent for sand flies, and reserve Buccan and Butch's Island Chop House early in the stay, since both take reservations. Off property, the Grenadines are the draw, and a day trip to Bequia or the Tobago Cays is the highlight of many stays.
What is the food like at each resort?
Food comes up on almost every honeymoon call, and it's one of the biggest differences between these two islands. St. Lucia gives you more restaurants, spread across three resorts. St. Vincent has fewer, but some of them you won't find at any other Sandals.
St. Lucia: 28 restaurants across three resorts
Because of the swap program, staying at any one of the three St. Lucia resorts gets you into all 28 restaurants on the island. Here's what each resort brings.
Sandals St. Lucia Grand Bay (formerly Grande St. Lucian) has 12 restaurants, the most on the island. Gordon's on the Pier is the one couples talk about: seafood at the end of a pier over the water, and a sunset dinner worth planning around. Bombay Club (Indian), Kimonos (teppanyaki), Soy (sushi), Toscanini's (Italian) and the Jerk Shack easily fill out a week. Gordon's, Bombay Club and Kimonos need reservations.
Sandals St. Lucia La Toc (formerly Regency La Toc) has 10 restaurants and the dressiest dinner on the island. La Toc, the French restaurant, is your one night to dress up. It requires evening attire and a reservation. The Pitons (Caribbean), Armando's (Italian), Neptune's (Mediterranean) and the Cricketer's Pub cover the rest. The resort sits on a hillside, so a few of the restaurants are a bit of a walk.
Sandals St. Lucia Halcyon Beach is the smallest, with six restaurants. Kelly's Dockside, grilled seafood right on the water, is the signature dinner, and everything here is resort casual. If you stay at Halcyon, plan to take the shuttle to the other two resorts a few nights.
Good to know: Kimonos and Soy are at all three resorts, so the 28 includes some repeats. Dinner at another resort also means a shuttle ride of roughly 25 to 45 minutes. Pick a few exchange nights instead of trying to do it every night.
St. Vincent: 11 restaurants, all on property
Sandals Saint Vincent has 11 restaurants and some of the most interesting food Sandals serves anywhere. Buccan is the headliner: open-air and family-style, with local dishes cooked over fire. It's a guest favorite and needs a reservation. Gatsu Gatsu (Japanese robata and sushi) only exists here and at Sandals Curaçao (formerly Sandals Royal Curaçao). Butch's Island Chop House is your steakhouse night, and it also takes reservations. Scrimshaw does seafood, and Parisol, the beach club grill, is perfect for long, lazy lunches. No restaurant here requires formal attire.
The tradeoff is simple. There's no exchange program, so every meal is at your resort. For five to seven nights that's plenty, and you'll never have to plan dinner around a shuttle schedule.
My take on the food: If food is a big part of how you picture your honeymoon and you're staying a week or longer, St. Lucia wins on choice. That's especially true if you stay at Grand Bay or La Toc and treat the other resorts as extras. If you'd rather every dinner be a short walk from your room, and you want restaurants that feel new, St. Vincent holds its own. Buccan alone is worth a night.
What is there to do outside the resort?
For couples who plan to leave the resort for a day or two, this can decide it. Excursions are not included in Sandals rates. They can be booked through Island Routes, Sandals' own tour company, or arranged privately ahead of the trip, and the popular ones fill up, so booking in advance is worth it. Once you book your stay with me, I can help plan and book excursions on either island.
St. Lucia
- Catamaran to Soufrière and the Pitons. A sail down the west coast, usually with a snorkel stop and lunch. The easiest way to see the Pitons from the north-coast resorts.
- Sulphur Springs. Billed as the world's only drive-in volcano, with warm volcanic mud baths to soak in.
- Diamond Falls Botanical Gardens. Gardens, a waterfall and mineral baths, a short drive from Sulphur Springs.
- Gros Piton hike. A guided climb of about 4 to 5 hours round trip, with views over Petit Piton from the top.
- Rainforest aerial tram and zipline. Rainforest Adventures, inland from Castries, combines an aerial tram, a zipline course and a guided trail.
- Gros Islet Friday night street party. Grilled food, music and a lively local crowd, close to Grand Bay.
St. Vincent
- Tobago Cays catamaran day. Five uninhabited islands in a protected marine park, reachable only by boat, with snorkeling among sea turtles. A full day, and the highlight of many stays.
- Bequia. A short boat ride away, with some of the best beaches in the Grenadines and a relaxed harbor town for lunch.
- Dark View Falls. Twin waterfalls stacked one above the other, reached across a bamboo bridge, with a natural pool for swimming.
- Wallilabou Bay. The Pirates of the Caribbean filming location on the leeward coast, easy to pair with Dark View Falls.
- La Soufrière volcano hike. A demanding guided climb to the crater rim of the island's active volcano. Start early, before the clouds roll in.
- Vermont Nature Trail. An easier rainforest walk with a good chance of spotting the St. Vincent parrot.
The difference: St. Lucia has the classic bucket-list excursions, the Pitons, the mud baths and the rainforest tram, though most of them sit in the southwest around Soufrière, so plan on a full day or a boat ride from the resorts. St. Vincent is the stronger pick for couples who love being on the water, since the Grenadines, the Tobago Cays and Bequia are right on its doorstep.
Getting there: flights and transfers
Most travelers to St. Lucia fly into Hewanorra International Airport (UVF) on the island's southern tip, which has the most nonstop flights from the US. The Sandals resorts are on the north and west coast, so the included transfer is a scenic but winding drive: about an hour to La Toc and Halcyon Beach, and about 1.5 to 2 hours to Grand Bay. Couples who would rather skip the drive can opt in to a ferry transfer up the coast instead, usually about $160 per person each way, or add a helicopter transfer, which takes minutes and doubles as a first look at the island from the air.
St. Vincent's Argyle International Airport (SVD) has fewer routes from the US. American Airlines flies nonstop from Miami and seasonally from Charlotte, and JetBlue flies nonstop from New York JFK. Delta ended its Atlanta service in September 2026. The road to the resort winds through the mountains and takes about 45 minutes. Butler-level guests can choose a complimentary boat transfer instead, but it has to be requested before arrival.
Door to door, the two islands often come out closer than expected. St. Lucia usually has the easier flights, while St. Vincent has the shorter drive once you land. Compare the full travel day, not only the fare, especially if you are flying out the day after the wedding. Once you book your stay with me, I can help with flights and routing too, including the best connection from your home airport.
Which is better for a honeymoon, St. Lucia or St. Vincent?
Choose St. Lucia if you want the most flight options, want variety across the week with three resorts to use, have the Pitons on your list, or like the idea of an overwater bungalow at Grand Bay with two more resorts to explore.
Choose St. Vincent if you want the newest Sandals resort, a two-story overwater villa, or a quieter island where the resort feels like your own corner of the Caribbean.
Five tips before you book
- 01
Book inside a sale window, and check Wednesdays. Sandals runs its biggest promotions a few times a year, and the Black Friday sale above covers stays through 2028. New 777 deals post every Wednesday with an extra 7% off seven room categories, on top of whatever sale is running.
- 02
Price both islands for the same dates. Room categories, credits and free nights differ by resort, so the gap between the two can be smaller or larger than expected.
- 03
Mind the season. December through April is the driest, most reliable stretch on both islands, and it books up first. Hurricane season runs June through November, when rates often drop and good travel insurance matters more.
- 04
In St. Vincent, pre-select the boat transfer if you are booking a Butler-level room. It is faster and far more scenic than the road.
- 05
Choose the room for how you will use it. Butler-level rooms add a butler, in-room dining and, at most Sandals resorts, private transfers. On a short stay, that service is often worth more than a better view.
Ready to price both islands?
Journeys with JB books Sandals in St. Lucia and St. Vincent. Share your dates and budget, and you will get both islands priced side by side, with any current Sandals savings applied.
Plan Your Honeymoon
Curated through Journeys with JB's trusted travel partnerships · Fully customizable to your dates and travel style
Frequently Asked
Which is better for a honeymoon, Sandals St. Lucia or Sandals St. Vincent?
St. Lucia suits couples who want easier flights, more variety and the Pitons, since a stay at one of its three Sandals resorts includes the other two. St. Vincent suits couples who want the newest Sandals resort, a two-story overwater villa and a quieter, less visited island.
Can you use all three Sandals resorts in St. Lucia?
Yes. Guests at Sandals St. Lucia Grand Bay, Sandals St. Lucia La Toc and Sandals St. Lucia Halcyon Beach can dine and use the amenities at all three, with shuttles between them included.
Does Sandals St. Vincent have overwater villas?
Yes. Sandals Saint Vincent has ten two-story overwater villas, the first of their kind for Sandals, with glass floors and open-air day beds on the upper level.
How do you get to Sandals St. Vincent from the US?
Fly into Argyle International Airport (SVD). American Airlines flies nonstop from Miami and seasonally from Charlotte, and JetBlue flies nonstop from New York JFK. The road transfer to the resort takes about 45 minutes, and Butler-level guests can request a boat transfer instead.
Which island has better excursions, St. Lucia or St. Vincent?
St. Lucia has the classic sights: a catamaran to the Pitons, the Sulphur Springs mud baths, the Gros Piton hike and the rainforest aerial tram. St. Vincent is better for couples who love the water, with catamaran days to the Tobago Cays to snorkel with sea turtles, trips to Bequia, and Dark View Falls. Excursions are booked separately from the Sandals rate on both islands.
Which airport do you fly into for Sandals St. Lucia?
Most travelers fly into Hewanorra International Airport (UVF) on the island's southern tip, where nearly all nonstop flights from the US land. The included Sandals transfer takes about an hour to La Toc and Halcyon Beach and about 1.5 to 2 hours to Grand Bay. Couples who would rather not drive can opt in to a ferry transfer, usually about $160 per person each way, or a helicopter transfer.
Is there a Sandals Black Friday sale in 2026?
Yes. The Sandals Black Friday sale runs through December 1, 2026 for stays through December 31, 2028, with savings of up to 65%, up to $2,000 in instant booking credit and up to $750 in air credit on qualifying stays. It includes the resorts in St. Lucia and St. Vincent, and it stacks with the weekly 777 deals.
What are Sandals 777 deals?
Every Wednesday, Sandals features seven room categories with an extra 7% off for seven days. The discount applies on top of the promotion already running, so a room on that week's list costs less than the same room the week before or after.